1929 Hebron massacre


This is a free translation of a Yiddish transcript of a taped interview made some 30 years ago with the late Rabbi Boruch Kaplan, who was a principal of the Beis Yaakov Girls School in Brooklyn, and who was a student in the Hebron yeshiva (religious school) in 1929 at the time of the killing of a number of Jews by some Arabs. Rabbi Kaplan explains how events unfolded, and how it was the arrogant and cowardly Zionists who perpetrated the events by provoking the Arabs. He also adds some comments about events at the time he recounted this story, some 30 years ago.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

When I was in Hebron in 1929, there occurred the tragic massacre of over twenty yeshiva students, great scholars, plus another forty members of the Jewish community. I would like to describe the error that has circulated in Jewish communities – a horrible error, that accuses the Arabs in Hebron of being murderers who attacked the Jews simply because the Arabs were “bad people.” In order to correct the record, this error must be corrected. The Arabs were very friendly people, and the Jewish People in Hebron lived together with them and had very friendly relations with them. They worked for Jews, and everybody got along just fine.

To take just one example, I used to have the habit of walking a mile or two out of town all by myself to visit a tree that was believed to be the tree where our patriarch Abraham met the three angels, as described in Genesis. I especially enjoyed visiting the tree in the summertime. Along the way I would talk to the Arabs, though it was mostly using our hands because I didn’t speak any Arabic. Interestingly enough, no one in the yeshiva ever told me it was dangerous to go by myself among the Arabs. We just lived with them, and got along very well.

I have also seen a letter from the Grand Rabbi of the Gerrer Hassidim of those days, Rabbi Avraham Mordechai Alter of Poland, regarding his trip to the Holy Land during the days when people were talking about emigrating to Palestine. He wanted to find out what kind of people the Arabs of Palestine were, in order to be able to advise people whether to move there or not. He wrote in his letter that the Arabs were a very friendly and fine people.

Therefore it’s necessary to set the record straight about the accusations that the Arabs were terrible killers who liked attacking Jews. This was never the situation at all!

Today’s wicked Zionists are just like their predecessors, who were responsible for causing terrible suffering in Palestine with their wars with the Arabs, may G-d have mercy. At that time in 1929, the Zionists had a slogan arguing that the Western Wall in Jerusalem was a Jewish “national symbol.” Of course, the Arabs disagreed with this idea, considering that they had control of the location for over 1,100 years.

However, the Zionist mobs were yelling that “The Wall is ours!” It’s hard to understand why they felt that way considering they have no connection to the Jewish holy places whatsoever. An argument erupted in the Jewish newspapers about establishing a permanent prayer area for Jews at the Wall. This provoked the Arabs, and the rabbi of Jerusalem at the time, Rabbi Yosef Chaim Zonnenfeld begged them to stop and to be appreciative to the Arabs for allowing Jews to pray at the Wall for so many centuries undisturbed. However, the Zionists wanted a permanent setup under their control.

The Zionists refused to heed the calls of Rabbi Zonnenfeld, and they called a large meeting of Jews in Jerusalem – supposedly some 10,000 people showed up. One of the speakers was their “chief Rabbi” (Avraham Isaac Kook), who proclaimed, “Hear O Israel, the Wall is our Wall, the Wall is One” (which is a ridiculous pun on the blessing, “Hear O Israel, the Lord your G-d, the Lord is One”). This began the conflict at the time between the Zionists and the Arabs.

Afterwards, we were studying at the yeshiva in Hebron, and saw a bunch of boys in short pants carrying weapons on bicycles and motorcycles, running around the streets of Hebron. We were very worried about this. What were they up to?

In brief, our rabbi, the supervisor of our religious academy, Rabbi Moshe Mordechai Epstein, called them for a meeting, but they refused. He was forced to go over to them, and asked them what they were up to. He accused them of wanting to provoke the Arabs. They responded that they were coming to protect us!! We cried out, “Woe is us! G-d have mercy!” They didn’t want to leave town until it was too late!

These arrogant cowards only ran away when the local leaders of the Arabs called for a mass meeting of the people of the surrounding Arab villages. But it was too late; the Arabs got organized, and the Mufti called on his people to be ready Friday night when the yeshiva would be attending prayers. Of course, the yeshiva itself was anti-Zionist, but the Arabs didn’t know to distinguish between us and the Zionists. Sadly they attacked and killed some of our people, including the great scholar, Rabbi Shmuel Rosenhaltz.

The next morning we heard about the excitement in town, and even worse, we heard the crying and shouting. I and a friend, Avraham Ushpener, lived in an apartment that was part of a three-story building leased by a Jew from an Arab. We could hear all the noise from our apartment on the third floor. We were terrified to let the Arabs in because we knew how angry they had become, but a while later things calmed down. In total, some 65 people were killed. On the other side of town, however, the Jews were spared.

Why am I telling this story? It is because I wanted to describe how the wicked Zionists, both today and in those days, were the cause of our suffering! They cooperated with the Nazis, and our religion teaches that a person who causes someone to sin is worse than someone who kills him.

It reminds me of an event recounted by Rabbi Moshe Schonfeld, who once visited Rabbi Avraham Yeshayahu Karelitz {Chazon Ish) when the Zionist state was established, and when there was fighting between the Zionists and the Arabs. Rabbi Schonfeld told Rabbi Karelitz about what was happening. Rabbi Karelitz told him that the crimes of the Zionists were much worse, because they were wicked heretics who were uprooting hundreds of thousands of Jews from their faith and that is much greater pain since our Sages stated that a person who causes another person to sin is much worse than if he kills him.

In our own days there is a Zionist leader (Begin), whose arrogance and selfishness is more important than anything else to him, and for which he is prepared to sacrifice hundreds and thousands of Jews. These heretics and evildoers, this Zionist leader of a state that killed the Judaism of the Yemenite and Moroccan Jews, and of many other Sephardic Jews! This is the work of these thugs and gangsters. And there are religious Jewish parties who dare to state that they love this man?! Everyone must know that the anger of the Arabs against us is only caused by the Zionists!

The Arabs were a friendly people to us, and I am a witness to it. We lived very well with them in Hebron. Rabbi Avraham Mordechai Alter, the Gerrer Rebbe, attested to this as well, and it is the accursed Zionists who caused them to hate us. The Zionists dare to use their power to expel the Arabs, and even today in Lebanon, they kill and butcher the Arabs; they wipe out whole villages with the airplanes they get from the United States.

Everyone should know who the murderers are – the Zionists are the biggest murderers in the world, who refuse to let the Jewish People live in peace either physically or spiritually!”

Click here to read the original Yiddish transcript.
Click here to listen to the tape of Rabbi Kaplan speaking in Yiddish. The story about the massacre begins 7 minutes into the tape.

2 comments:

  1. Wow, all that from a man who spoke neither Arabic nor Hebrew and hald less than 7 months in town? He was THAT knowledgable about the town to state that Jews and Arabs got along fine? As the son of Shlomo Slonim Dwek, who survived in a home where 22 were killed including his parents, brother, maternal grandparents and other family members (and students from that same yeshiva) I can state that he had no idea what he was talking about, mostly related fiction and as a member of Neteuri Karta- the source of the tape by the way- was not even in a position to talk about Judaism much less Jewish Life in Hebron.

    His guru Rav Herman plucked him out of New Haven, in the US, and sent him to Hebron just after sending his own son Nachum. Less than 7 months he stayed in Hebron, living down the street from Slobodka (Yeshiva K'nesset Yisrael).

    He claims that no one ever admonished students not to go amongst Arabs? In fact my great-grandfather Rav Ya'akov Yosef Slonim Dwek, the Chief Rabbi, used to warn them every Erev Shabbat. In fact? It was the students- like the speaker- who the Arabs wanted to kill most! My grandfather Dan Eliezer Slonim Dwek had given many sactuary when they begged him, thinking because he was the President of the Hebron Jewish Community as well as a bank manager who did business with many wealthy Arabs in town that he could save them. In fact, the Arabs told him to just give up the students and no other Jews would be bothered. My father's family was slaughtered for refusing to do it so for the speaker to flap his gums over something he knew next to nothing about is beyond degenerate and to use it to grind a political axe males him the worst of the bottom feeders, dead or not. All the good work his wife did with Beis Yakov [sic] does not earn his memoury a pass for blatantly violating Holochot Mesirah and to do so while manufacturing garbage.

    Zionists caused it? What caused the 1834 Pogrom in Hebron? 1799? 1787 Bloodlibel? Not more than two generations ever existed since the Arabs invaded the town in 638 CE/AD when local Jews were not slaughtered in large numbers. It had zero to do with Zionism.

    al Haj al Amin al Husseini, the so called "Grand Mufti" orchestrated the pogrom. It was not the only one. In the preceding week Jews were slaughtered in Tzafat (Safed), Tiberias, Motzah, Jerusalem and elsewhere, all at Husseini's direction.

    The Wall, HaKotel? It was because Arabs- who had limited Jews to a 6 meter wide alley that had wagons rolling through it if the wanted to pray there suddenly demanded that the Jewish Agency sign a document ceding ownership of the site to al Waq'f, the "Grand Mufti's"agency, in a document that stated that it has always been Islamic property and always would be. Truth be told? The Zionists wanted to sign it! Revisionists prptested but the Revisionists were a tiny minority. It was Rav Kook the Elder, an ultra-religious Jew, who led the dissention and he did the right thing.

    As for Zionists in shorts running around Hebron? Utterly ridiculous. Two men from the Haganah came and stayed in our home, meeting with my grandfather, who as President had the decision in alliwing Haganah deployment. My grandfather refused because he believed it would exacerbate tensions. They left two days before the killing began and never spent ten minutes outside our home unless arriving and departing.


    The speaker shamed himself with his ignorance and desecrated the memouries of 67 Jewish victims.


    Rachamim Dwek, Sussiya, YESHA.

    ReplyDelete
  2. If this be so, it apparently did not harm the overall sense of harmony and security of Jewish inhabitants. The Palestinian Jews, including the Rabbi of Jerusalem did not want the European Zionist Jews in Palestine.
    The devil Zionist Jews before the establishment of Israel used what they called "whisperers" to spread rumors amongst the Palestinians that the Jews were doing things they really weren't doing. They did the same all over the Middle East spreading terror through their false flags to cause the Jews to flee to the cursed Israel. The Rabbi above speaks the truth.

    ReplyDelete

If you sit by a river long enough, you'll see the body of your enemy float by.
Old Japanese proverb